I always completely turn off my phone when I enter a cinema. Not only on do not disturb – completely off. I mention this not from a place of judgment, or to imply that the ghost of Billy Wilder will materialize to congratulate me. I consider it as one of life's minor indulgences: for no less than a couple of hours, I exist as entirely unreachable. I leave my phone powered down during the scroll as well. It strikes me as decadent to linger as other patrons trickle away, bathed in the light of the scrolling names.
And, increasingly, by the light of the Letterboxd application.
Over 26 million individuals utilize Letterboxd, a cinema-tracking platform. Similar to the Criterion Collection, it has evolved into a cultural signifier for a specific type of aficionado who promotes new releases and delights in unearthing old classics. Users score and write about films, and the funniest or most articulate critiques rise to prominence, encouraging cinephiles to craft thoughtful responses.
"If I don't jot down my ideas immediately after the credits roll, my write-ups are far less coherent and articulate," said Josh Stern.
In a recent outing to the theater, the credits had barely started before the gentleman ahead of me started composing his review. Not far away, a pair remained seated, heads bowed, jotting down their individual impressions.
The renowned director David Lynch shared some wisdom: record every brilliant thought the precise instant it occurs to you. If you don't, it could be forgotten, and, as he phrased it: "Losing a great idea, you want to commit suicide." Although Lynch advised hopeful creators, a similar ethos fits the Letterboxd experience.
Josh Stern, a young student in New York, always composes his critiques while still in the cinema.
"Should I fail to articulate my impressions promptly when the film concludes, my write-ups are much less coherent and articulate," he stated. "It takes some time. I'm pretty slow, and my girlfriend isn't fond of it."
He visits the movies frequently – 182 times last year – and is on a friendly footing with the ushers, who at times have to ask him to leave so they can begin cleaning the aisles. He thinks it reasonable to take advantage of the closing scroll: "When you pay for a cinema ticket, the credits are part of the movie."
Letterboxd's most passionate users credit the platform with reviving excitement around a challenged film industry, where output has decreased and unemployment is up. (Letterboxd also has the type of audience data brands desire – its primary cohort of users is aged 18 and 24, followed by 25 to 35.)
Hype generates additional buzz; eagerly anticipated movies experience a rash of engagement on Letterboxd immediately after the premiere showtimes. The highest-rated critique of a divisive adaptation – "Emily Brontë died in the 19th century yet this adaptation is still the greatest injustice that has ever happened to her" – has garnered more than 50,000 hearts. Another recent film produced this contrast to a major artist's concert film: "that other tour film found dead."
"It's somewhat a compulsion," said one user, a thirty-three-year-old New Yorker who has a career in marketing. He also prefers to write reviews during the credits. "Reflecting on what you just saw, immediately after you saw it, enhances the artistic experience. It clarifies the central themes of a film. If it evokes a sensation of a warm hug, that's not necessarily something you retain five hours down the line."
He feels most motivated to critique a film if it was exceptionally good – or terrible. For example: he recently watched a big-budget project. "I was so appalled by how utterly terrible it was, that I was keen to pull out my phone and give it a half-star score," he said. (He is a more critical critic than some reviewers, who awarded the film three stars, describing it as "smart and entertaining fare.")
Dakota Chester, a 28-year-old New Yorker who works in social media, watched an acclaimed feature at a local theater and remained to write the write-up ("it received a perfect score"). He has witnessed poorer etiquette: people taking out their phones to log the movie they are in the middle of watching. "That irritates me," he said.
One of the movie industry's most persistent tales describes a showing of an 1896 motion picture that featured a train entering a station. Film was in its infancy and – as per this largely discredited anecdote – the image of a locomotive heading straight toward the camera shocked the spectators so much that people ran away in panic.
Over a century later, movie theater manners is just as questionable. Apparently, individuals remember how to behave in a theater anymore, particularly when the lights go down: viewers snap photos of the projection, smuggle in strong-smelling food, and, as seen during a cultural moment, at times get into fights.
Some individuals have resorted to social media to discuss the appropriateness of "Letterboxding" throughout the closing scroll. When one social media user